I'd heard of the RNA world, but I hadn't realized that there were so many other competing molecules and that the new trend in the field moved on entirely from single biologically known molecules, to mixes of molecules or less 'living' objects. I think it's interesting to see how a scientific field tries different things when they get stuck.
shevy-java 1 days ago [-]
Well, RNA/DNA is of course the most logical assumption.
Which other "competing molecules" are there? How does that translate to giving rise to a bacterium? There is no explanation here. Just astrobiologists claiming that it must have happened outside of planet Earth. I think that is total rubbish nonsense. They just want to make their field sound more exciting.
> tries different things when they get stuck.
Ok, that's fine. The question is: how do their claims lead to a functionally logical pathway of life's origin(s)?
There's also "lipid world", since cells required a way to isolate their internal processes from the environment, the theory is that the lipid membrane evolved first, with biological processes then able to evolve within its protective membrane.
If I can expand on why I like this - my understanding from the article is that two realizations came from experiments:
1. No one could produce any plausibly simple self replicating RNA structure
2. Chance events that generate biologically relevant molecules generate them in huge varieties. So restricting yourself to only one type of molecule isn't necessary.
A third point that I've heard before but isn't mentioned in the article - there's also no reason that the original life needs to resemble anything found today. Even basic candidates like RNA or lipids soups are essentially free food in today's environment.
As I understand it, the best we could hope for is demonstrating in the lab a series of 'realistic' chemical reactions that generate molecules that can both reproduce and mutate, and perhaps more ambitiously that such molecules mutate and eventually begin to build RNA, DNA, proteins. There's no guarantee that such an experiment even exists (real world timescales and sheer magnitude means that the chance event could be extremely low), so even this best case condition isn't possible. But given this fact and 1&2, I thought their experiments in the latter half of the article on a minimal set of amino acids, and on self-catalyzing and seemingly mutating benzene rings were interesting ways at trying to make some potential progress.
About competing molecules, they mention in the article:
"There was also a lipid world, in which the molecules that form cell membranes and contain cellular chemistry came first. There was a protein or peptide world, a virus world, a coenzyme world, a zinc world, and even a clay world"
This is outside my field of expertise so I can't verify this, though I've heard people talk about lipids being more necessary since they make small enclosed environments for all the interesting chemical reactions to happen.
I saw your other comment and I agree there are plenty of pretty stupid sounding phrases. I take this for granted (quanta has plenty of this, and my own university adopts the stupidest slogans imaginable). But regardless I do appreciate learning a bit about recent progress field I wouldn't normally read on. I also didn't get much from astrobiology sections - more interested in the chemistry parts.
abecedarius 1 days ago [-]
You might enjoy Freeman Dyson's version of "total rubbish nonsense", his short book Origins of Life or his paper it was based on. It explains a mathematician's toy model of metabolism-first origins.
amelius 1 days ago [-]
> Which other "competing molecules" are there?
Look into chirality.
Basically the same molecules but exact mirror copies.
cajal 23 hours ago [-]
what does this comment even suggest to offer as a competing molecule? what an empty statement.
exe34 1 days ago [-]
> Just astrobiologists claiming that it must have happened outside of planet Earth
It would make N go from zero to 1, that's huge!
OgsyedIE 2 days ago [-]
What is life and the property of being living a subset of? What broader concept consistently generalises life?
Without a determination of whether the above question is meaningful, the field of biology shall have no foundations - George C. Williams
adrianN 2 days ago [-]
There are some attempts to define life based on maintaining entropy gradients and reproduction that are fairly general.
AndrewDucker 2 days ago [-]
Autopoiesis.
(Systems that generate themselves)
usrnm 1 days ago [-]
And viruses are the most common counterexample. I never really bought the simple solution of not considering them to be alive simply because they don't fit the definition
thephyber 1 days ago [-]
The field of biology is VERY familiar with trying to deal with things that violate the definitions/ terminology. There's a valid reason why viruses aren't "alive".
kakacik 1 days ago [-]
crystals too?
317070 1 days ago [-]
So a meme is alive, but infertile people are not?
Just to point out that it is more complicated and there is a reason people devote considerable headspace to the question.
bmitc 8 hours ago [-]
The comment you replied to isn't saying that systems that exhibit autopoiesis are alive. They are saying that autopoiesis is a general concept of which life my be a specific example of.
matt-attack 1 days ago [-]
Infertile people are comprised of perfectly fertile cells. So their cells are certainly alive.
317070 21 hours ago [-]
So the country Canada is alive too, made up of a lot of living people?
cajal 23 hours ago [-]
what a silly criteria for defining a field. pseudo philosophical nonsense designed to make tech bros feel intellectually superior.
what is physics and the property of physics a subset of? are molecules interacting through electromagnetic forces physics? cool, well that’s also neuroscience. give me the laws of motion of a thought. where does physics stop and psychology begin? well sounds like physics has no foundation then.
poslathian 1 days ago [-]
No mention of ben Einstein and dissipative adaptation?
zkmon 1 days ago [-]
And here we are thinking that mind is separate from the biology and chemistry or even the physical world.
rramadass 1 days ago [-]
In one sense, it is. Regardless of its origins (i.e. Consciousness vs. Mind, Emergent property of biological system etc.) we emote/feel/think/act/live subjectively in our mind and thus it has a distinct identity of its own which must be managed on its own terms.
In Hindu philosophies, the concept of "Mind" is defined as Antahkarana i.e. inner organ (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antahkarana) with three specific aspects viz. 1) Ahamkara (Self-Identity/Ego/etc.) 2) Buddhi (Intellect/Reasoning/Rationality/etc.) 3) Manas (Sensing/Perception/etc.)
Note that the above is a logical/functional mapping and not a physical one. However it is interesting to also note that Hindu philosophies (specifically Samkhya) say that though mind is subtle it is just another evolute of Nature (aka Prakriti) and thus subject to its laws. There is a very distinct separation between Consciousness/Awareness (aka Purusha and not part of nature/prakriti) and Mind (evolute of prakriti).
This actually maps very nicely with the biological idea that consciousness is an emergent property of the complex biological organism and hence distinct for each organism. Samkhya simply states it as an axiom.
The key point is to separate out the contents of awareness from awareness itself. I can affect your mind (i.e. contents of awareness) with psychedelics but not your true consciousness. Coma patients in a vegetative state can have parts of their mind shutdown but their consciousness is still very much "there".
1 days ago [-]
rramadass 2 days ago [-]
Good article, longish but worth the read.
It is just amazing that while we know the constituents of all earthly matter (made up from the elements of the periodic table) to a high degree of precision we still don't have a definite idea of how they give rise to "Life" (the definition itself is problematic). Molecular systems undergoing chemical processes somehow give rise to "Biology".
As the article says, "Life" needs a "compartment" (i.e. cell) to begin and grow. It must hold 1) a mechanism to store information (for further propagation) 2) a mechanism to generate energy and do work 3) a mechanism to evolve further. variations.
You start with a chemical soup with various elements/molecules/ions in various levels of concentration, provide energy to the system to encourage reactions and see what happens.
Applying "Complex Systems Science" theories tells us that at a certain scale and with right set of conditions a "primordial cell" maybe formed. Note that there might be multiple types of these cells.
Once this happened it started influencing the very chemical reactions in which it could participate using feedback loops i.e. starts exhibiting "functions/behaviours". To understand this part, i found the book Vehicles: Experiments in Synthetic Psychology by Valentino Braitenberg which shows how "complex perceived behaviour" can arise from extremely simple rules, useful - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braitenberg_vehicle
Add "survival of the fittest" over time and you get to where we are today.
shevy-java 1 days ago [-]
> Molecules entangled themselves in self-sustaining, self-reproducing loops.
Now - one can derive to this conclusion, but the problem is: when you make such a statement, it is only speculation. You have to prove it. And nobody has been able to prove that statement so far.
Yes, you can prove that you have the molecules necessary, e. g. under abiotic conditions. But you need to prove it still that this relates to a system where information is stored and transmitted. Which, again, nobody has done so far.
Thus, making such a claim, even if logical (because after all you need to assume that life as such, is also logical, from a scientific point of view), you need to explain it. The article does not explain it. The article does not refer to other articles that explain it either.
> Over time, these systems became more complex.
Ok, that makes sense. Now ... HOW did these systems originate exactly? This is missing. You need to explain the bootstrapping part.
> Life invented new ways to move, and to capture, store, and use energy.
Ok this is getting worse. Now the author injects "Life" here. What is Life? Did it invent anything? How exactly?
Again - we can assume there must be a logical pathway here, if we do not believe in an invisible god writing RNA/DNA, but the article totally dodges that question.
> Through cycles of birth, reproduction, and death;
They seem to refer to a stage where a cell already existed. What about the parts before that point? It is quite easy to go from a cell to anything more complex. The foundation explanation is missing. Even in the RNA world theory.
> Then, at some point, life gained a sense of itself
Now it is getting worse.
> Scientists clashed over which type of molecule — RNA, lipids, proteins, and metabolites are prime suspects
That's not really true. Which theory claims that lipids played
a major role and why? I mean, from a simple logical assumption,
RNA/DNA is or must be the central part. If an author casually
mentions lipids, then I wonder if that author isn't just totally
clueless.
> Life’s origins are not purely a chemistry problem. “It’s not a linear reaction. … There’s no single E = mc2 and that’s origin of life’s formula,” said Betül Kaçar, an astrobiologist and evolutionary biologist
I know astrobiologists love to claim life originated from outside Earth. None of them explain how. We can always claim external reasons which can (most likely) never be proven. Or perhaps in the far distant future. I don't buy any of that. I am 100% certain that life originated on Earth, in a logical fashion. Now, the problem still is how to prove that.
> “This is biology; it doesn’t follow any rules. That’s what makes it so sophisticated and exciting.”
Ok, I stopped reading past that point. That article is total gutter trash.
Of course all what you see even on the molecular level, follows certain rules.
Anyone not understanding that is not a scientist.
https://www.quantamagazine.org/tag/origins-of-life-week/
Which other "competing molecules" are there? How does that translate to giving rise to a bacterium? There is no explanation here. Just astrobiologists claiming that it must have happened outside of planet Earth. I think that is total rubbish nonsense. They just want to make their field sound more exciting.
> tries different things when they get stuck.
Ok, that's fine. The question is: how do their claims lead to a functionally logical pathway of life's origin(s)?
There's the minority Amyloid world [1] hypothesis. Amyloid has some interesting properties.
[1] https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s00018-018-2797-9
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC9986030/
1. No one could produce any plausibly simple self replicating RNA structure
2. Chance events that generate biologically relevant molecules generate them in huge varieties. So restricting yourself to only one type of molecule isn't necessary.
A third point that I've heard before but isn't mentioned in the article - there's also no reason that the original life needs to resemble anything found today. Even basic candidates like RNA or lipids soups are essentially free food in today's environment.
As I understand it, the best we could hope for is demonstrating in the lab a series of 'realistic' chemical reactions that generate molecules that can both reproduce and mutate, and perhaps more ambitiously that such molecules mutate and eventually begin to build RNA, DNA, proteins. There's no guarantee that such an experiment even exists (real world timescales and sheer magnitude means that the chance event could be extremely low), so even this best case condition isn't possible. But given this fact and 1&2, I thought their experiments in the latter half of the article on a minimal set of amino acids, and on self-catalyzing and seemingly mutating benzene rings were interesting ways at trying to make some potential progress.
About competing molecules, they mention in the article: "There was also a lipid world, in which the molecules that form cell membranes and contain cellular chemistry came first. There was a protein or peptide world, a virus world, a coenzyme world, a zinc world, and even a clay world" This is outside my field of expertise so I can't verify this, though I've heard people talk about lipids being more necessary since they make small enclosed environments for all the interesting chemical reactions to happen.
I saw your other comment and I agree there are plenty of pretty stupid sounding phrases. I take this for granted (quanta has plenty of this, and my own university adopts the stupidest slogans imaginable). But regardless I do appreciate learning a bit about recent progress field I wouldn't normally read on. I also didn't get much from astrobiology sections - more interested in the chemistry parts.
Look into chirality.
Basically the same molecules but exact mirror copies.
It would make N go from zero to 1, that's huge!
Without a determination of whether the above question is meaningful, the field of biology shall have no foundations - George C. Williams
(Systems that generate themselves)
Just to point out that it is more complicated and there is a reason people devote considerable headspace to the question.
what is physics and the property of physics a subset of? are molecules interacting through electromagnetic forces physics? cool, well that’s also neuroscience. give me the laws of motion of a thought. where does physics stop and psychology begin? well sounds like physics has no foundation then.
In Hindu philosophies, the concept of "Mind" is defined as Antahkarana i.e. inner organ (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antahkarana) with three specific aspects viz. 1) Ahamkara (Self-Identity/Ego/etc.) 2) Buddhi (Intellect/Reasoning/Rationality/etc.) 3) Manas (Sensing/Perception/etc.)
Note that the above is a logical/functional mapping and not a physical one. However it is interesting to also note that Hindu philosophies (specifically Samkhya) say that though mind is subtle it is just another evolute of Nature (aka Prakriti) and thus subject to its laws. There is a very distinct separation between Consciousness/Awareness (aka Purusha and not part of nature/prakriti) and Mind (evolute of prakriti).
This actually maps very nicely with the biological idea that consciousness is an emergent property of the complex biological organism and hence distinct for each organism. Samkhya simply states it as an axiom.
The key point is to separate out the contents of awareness from awareness itself. I can affect your mind (i.e. contents of awareness) with psychedelics but not your true consciousness. Coma patients in a vegetative state can have parts of their mind shutdown but their consciousness is still very much "there".
It is just amazing that while we know the constituents of all earthly matter (made up from the elements of the periodic table) to a high degree of precision we still don't have a definite idea of how they give rise to "Life" (the definition itself is problematic). Molecular systems undergoing chemical processes somehow give rise to "Biology".
As the article says, "Life" needs a "compartment" (i.e. cell) to begin and grow. It must hold 1) a mechanism to store information (for further propagation) 2) a mechanism to generate energy and do work 3) a mechanism to evolve further. variations.
You start with a chemical soup with various elements/molecules/ions in various levels of concentration, provide energy to the system to encourage reactions and see what happens.
Applying "Complex Systems Science" theories tells us that at a certain scale and with right set of conditions a "primordial cell" maybe formed. Note that there might be multiple types of these cells.
Once this happened it started influencing the very chemical reactions in which it could participate using feedback loops i.e. starts exhibiting "functions/behaviours". To understand this part, i found the book Vehicles: Experiments in Synthetic Psychology by Valentino Braitenberg which shows how "complex perceived behaviour" can arise from extremely simple rules, useful - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Braitenberg_vehicle
Add "survival of the fittest" over time and you get to where we are today.
Now - one can derive to this conclusion, but the problem is: when you make such a statement, it is only speculation. You have to prove it. And nobody has been able to prove that statement so far.
Yes, you can prove that you have the molecules necessary, e. g. under abiotic conditions. But you need to prove it still that this relates to a system where information is stored and transmitted. Which, again, nobody has done so far.
Thus, making such a claim, even if logical (because after all you need to assume that life as such, is also logical, from a scientific point of view), you need to explain it. The article does not explain it. The article does not refer to other articles that explain it either.
> Over time, these systems became more complex.
Ok, that makes sense. Now ... HOW did these systems originate exactly? This is missing. You need to explain the bootstrapping part.
> Life invented new ways to move, and to capture, store, and use energy.
Ok this is getting worse. Now the author injects "Life" here. What is Life? Did it invent anything? How exactly?
Again - we can assume there must be a logical pathway here, if we do not believe in an invisible god writing RNA/DNA, but the article totally dodges that question.
> Through cycles of birth, reproduction, and death;
They seem to refer to a stage where a cell already existed. What about the parts before that point? It is quite easy to go from a cell to anything more complex. The foundation explanation is missing. Even in the RNA world theory.
> Then, at some point, life gained a sense of itself
Now it is getting worse.
> Scientists clashed over which type of molecule — RNA, lipids, proteins, and metabolites are prime suspects
That's not really true. Which theory claims that lipids played a major role and why? I mean, from a simple logical assumption, RNA/DNA is or must be the central part. If an author casually mentions lipids, then I wonder if that author isn't just totally clueless.
> Life’s origins are not purely a chemistry problem. “It’s not a linear reaction. … There’s no single E = mc2 and that’s origin of life’s formula,” said Betül Kaçar, an astrobiologist and evolutionary biologist
I know astrobiologists love to claim life originated from outside Earth. None of them explain how. We can always claim external reasons which can (most likely) never be proven. Or perhaps in the far distant future. I don't buy any of that. I am 100% certain that life originated on Earth, in a logical fashion. Now, the problem still is how to prove that.
> “This is biology; it doesn’t follow any rules. That’s what makes it so sophisticated and exciting.”
Ok, I stopped reading past that point. That article is total gutter trash.
Of course all what you see even on the molecular level, follows certain rules. Anyone not understanding that is not a scientist.